Inside the High-Stakes World of India’s Chief Selector
When former Indian fast bowler Ajit Agarkar took over as the BCCI’s chief selector in July 2023, few could have imagined the emotional and professional weight that came with the role. In a candid conversation at the NDTV World Summit 2025, Agarkar pulled back the curtain on what he calls the “most challenging job” of his career—even more than playing international cricket or commentating .
“There’s Nothing Else in Your Hand”
Agarkar’s now-viral quote—“Once you pick a squad of 15, there is nothing else in your hand”—captures the essence of his helplessness after selection decisions are made . Unlike on the field, where a bowler can adjust line and length or a batsman can shift stance, selectors must live with their choices long after the team sheet is published.
“It’s a challenging, hectic, high-demand job,” Agarkar admitted, emphasizing that the pressure isn’t just about picking winners—it’s about shaping careers, managing expectations, and weathering public backlash .
Why Being Chief Selector Tops Playing and Commentary
For a man who played 26 Tests and 191 ODIs for India, it’s telling that Agarkar ranks selection as his toughest gig. Here’s why:
- Irreversible Impact: One omission can derail a young player’s momentum.
- National Scrutiny: With over a billion cricket-crazy fans, every pick is dissected on social media and news channels.
- No Margin for Error: Unlike commentary—where opinions can be revised—selections are final and public.
“You can’t please everyone… and you shouldn’t try to,” Agarkar cautioned, acknowledging the impossibility of satisfying fans, experts, and players alike .
The Depth Dilemma: A Blessing and a Curse
India’s talent pool is deeper than ever. From domestic stalwarts to IPL breakout stars, the competition is fierce. But as Agarkar noted, this abundance makes the selector’s job harder, not easier .
“The depth of cricketers we have means every decision carries weight. You’re not just choosing a player—you’re potentially delaying someone else’s dream,” he explained.
Real Talk: Shami, Injuries, and Tough Calls
Agarkar didn’t shy away from addressing specific controversies. On veteran pacer Mohammed Shami’s absence from recent squads, he was clear: “If Mohammed Shami was fit, he’d be in the team” . This underscores a key principle in his selection philosophy: fitness and current form trump legacy.
Table: Agarkar’s Career Roles Compared
| Role | Key Challenge | Public Pressure |
|---|---|---|
| Player | Performance under match conditions | High |
| Commentator | Accuracy and insight in real-time | Medium |
| Chief Selector | Balancing talent, form, and future | Extreme |
What’s Next for Indian Cricket’s Gatekeeper?
As India prepares for upcoming ICC events and bilateral series, Agarkar’s selections will continue to be under the microscope. Yet, his grounded approach—prioritizing merit, fitness, and team balance—offers a blueprint for navigating the chaos.
For aspiring cricketers, his message is clear: “Keep performing. The selectors are watching.”