India’s shocking 2-0 home Test series loss to South Africa has ignited a firestorm of criticism—much of it aimed squarely at head coach Gautam Gambhir. Fans are calling for his head. Pundits are dissecting his every decision. But one of Indian cricket’s most respected voices has slammed this wave of negativity: none other than batting legend and former captain Sunil Gavaskar.
“Why blame him now?” Gavaskar shot back, challenging critics who are quick to point fingers while conveniently forgetting the team’s recent successes under Gambhir’s leadership . His defense isn’t just emotional—it’s rooted in logic, fairness, and a deep understanding of how cricket teams actually function. In this article, we unpack Gavaskar’s powerful take, analyze the context behind the South Africa collapse, and explore why scapegoating Gautam Gambhir is both misleading and counterproductive.
After losing both Tests at home—first in Kolkata by 30 runs, then in Guwahati by a staggering 408 runs—India’s aura of invincibility on home soil has been shattered . This marks their second consecutive home Test series whitewash in just over a year, a stat that has fueled public outrage.
As the team’s head coach, Gautam Gambhir has borne the brunt. Critics have questioned his team selections, his all-rounder-heavy template, and his post-match communication. Social media is ablaze with calls for his removal before the upcoming tours .
Stepping into this storm, Sunil Gavaskar offered a measured, authoritative rebuttal. He didn’t shy away from the disappointment—but he refused to let the coach take the fall alone.
“Why blame him now?” Gavaskar asked pointedly . He reminded everyone that coaches don’t bat, bowl, or field. “You can’t expect the coach to go out there and play the cover drive or take the wicket,” he noted, echoing a sentiment recently shared by R Ashwin .
His core message? Accountability is a team-wide responsibility—not a solo act. And targeting Gautam Gambhir ignores the fundamental truth that players must own their on-field failures.
One of Gavaskar’s sharpest criticisms was of the public’s selective memory. Just months earlier, India had celebrated historic Test series wins in Australia and South Africa under the same leadership structure.
Key achievements under Gambhir’s tenure include:
“When they win, everyone praises the system. When they lose, one man is thrown under the bus,” Gavaskar observed . This inconsistency, he argued, reflects a lack of understanding of how long-term team building works in elite cricket.
This is the million-dollar question. Modern cricket has elevated the coach’s role—but not to the point of omnipotence.
The coach’s job includes:
But ultimately, it’s the players who must:
As the International Cricket Council (ICC) notes in its coaching guidelines, the coach is a facilitator—not the performer .
Instead of fixating on Gautam Gambhir, a more constructive post-mortem would examine:
Blaming Gambhir alone distracts from these deeper, more complex problems.
Sunil Gavaskar’s defense of Gautam Gambhir isn’t about protecting a colleague—it’s about defending the integrity of cricket discourse. His question, “Why blame him now?”, cuts through the noise and demands accountability from all stakeholders: players, selectors, fans, and media alike.
The road ahead for Indian Test cricket requires reflection, not rage. It needs patience, not panic. And most of all, it needs a collective understanding that no single individual—no matter their title—can win or lose a Test match alone. As India regroups for its next challenge, Gavaskar’s voice serves as a crucial reminder: fairness and perspective matter more than ever.
For more on India’s Test strategy and future tours, see our in-depth guide on [INTERNAL_LINK:india-test-cricket-future].
With Washington Sundar and Tilak Varma facing fitness doubts, Team India is scrambling for a…
With their third SA20 title in four years—including a dramatic last-over heist against Pretoria Capitals—Sunrisers…
In a dramatic SA20 final at Newlands, Sunrisers Eastern Cape claimed their third consecutive title…
In a breathtaking display of power-hitting, Abhishek Sharma smashed the second-fastest T20I half-century by an…
In a dramatic but definitive turn, the Bangladesh Cricket Board has officially withdrawn from the…
Bangladesh Cricket Board (BCB) has laid down strict conditions for Shakib Al Hasan’s potential return…